My favorite shoes websites, in no particular order, are:
This site is powered by Amazon which makes me feel at ease. It also has free overnight shipping and return shipping. You can search either on Amazon or Endless and see the same shoes, however since shipping is always free with Endless I usually order through them. It is easy to narrow down by shoe size, style, price, etc. They almost always have my size in the style I'm looking for. Their prices can be on the higher end, but at the same time if you can't find it anywhere else, it may be worth it.
***I just took advantage of their 100% price guarantee. In a matter of hours I received an email confirming they were refunding the difference. You have 14 days from the ship date to take advantage of this. Act quickly as prices change. The website that I received the match from had upped their price 2 days later.****
If you know of a shoe brand and style name you want, try searching here for price comparison. Otherwise it is difficult and tedious to narrow down the selection. Shipping was very fast so no complaint there.
See review of Endless.
Don't knock it until you try it. Yes this is a website that sells other 'novelty' items but you really can't beat their shoe prices. I found a pair of killer peep toes for $17 that retailed for almost $70! A good site to visit if you need a pair of shoes to set one outfit off but can't justify dropping a lot of money on them. Search for coupons as I saved 10% online. Also protected by verisign. You have to pay for shipping unless you spend $100+ but still a good deal in my opinion.
Visit my shoe blog